Eyelash Tinting vs. Eyelash Extensions: Includes DIY at-Home Ideas

In the realm of beauty, the eyes have always been a focal point. From the dramatic allure of bold eyeliners to the flutter of luscious lashes, there’s no denying the impact of well-defined eyes. Among the myriad ways to enhance eyelashes, two popular methods stand out: eyelash tinting and eyelash extensions. Each offers its unique set of benefits and considerations, catering to diverse preferences and lifestyles. 

In this blog post, we’ll explore the differences between eyelash tint and eyelash extensions, their pros and cons, and even provide some DIY at-home ideas for those keen on experimenting.

Eyelash Tinting: The Subtle Enhancer

Eyelash tinting is a semi-permanent solution for achieving darker, more defined lashes without the need for daily mascara application. Using specially formulated dyes, professional technicians or at-home enthusiasts can darken the lashes, enhancing their appearance and providing a natural-looking frame to the eyes. Eyelash tinting typically lasts between 4 and 6 weeks, depending on individual lash growth cycles.

Pros of Eyelash Tinting

  • Time-saving: Say goodbye to the hassle of applying mascara daily. With eyelash tinting, your lashes remain dark and defined, even when you wake up in the morning.
  • Natural look: Unlike mascara or extensions, tinting offers a more subtle enhancement, perfect for those seeking a low-maintenance yet polished appearance.
  • Allergy-friendly: Many eyelash tinting products are formulated to be gentle on the eyes, making them suitable for individuals with sensitive skin or allergies to traditional makeup products.
  • Cost-effective: While initial salon visits for professional tinting may incur a cost, the long-lasting results can save money in the long run compared to purchasing mascara regularly.

Cons of Eyelash Tinting

  • Limited customisation: Unlike extensions, tinting primarily focuses on darkening the lashes’ colour and does not add length or volume. Invest in a good tint remover whenever you want to free up your lashes for a bit of time. 
  • Requires touch-ups: Tinting fades gradually over time, necessitating regular touch-ups to maintain the desired intensity.
  • Risk of irritation: While rare, there is a slight risk of irritation or allergic reaction to the tinting products, mainly if proper patch tests are not conducted beforehand.

DIY At-Home Eyelash Tinting

For those who prefer the convenience and privacy of home beauty treatments, DIY eyelash tint kits offer a viable option. Here’s a simple step-by-step guide:

  1. Preparation: Start by cleansing your lashes thoroughly to remove any traces of makeup or oil.
  2. Patch Test: Perform a patch test by applying a small amount of the tint solution behind your ear or on your inner elbow. Wait for 24 hours to ensure there is no adverse reaction.
  3. Application: Using the provided applicator or a disposable mascara wand, carefully apply the tint to your lashes, ensuring even coverage from root to tip.
  4. Wait: Follow the recommended processing time specified in the eyelash tint kit instructions. Typically, this ranges from 5 to 15 minutes.
  5. Remove: Gently wipe away the tint using a damp cotton pad or cloth. Be cautious to avoid getting the solution in your eyes.
  6. Moisturise: Finish by applying a nourishing lash serum or conditioner to keep your lashes healthy and hydrated.

Eyelash Extensions: The Glamorous Enhancer

Eyelash extensions offer a more dramatic and customisable approach to enhancing lashes. Individual synthetic fibers are bonded to natural lashes using adhesive, resulting in added length, volume, and curl. With proper maintenance, extensions can last anywhere from 4 to 6 weeks, making them a popular choice for special occasions or everyday glamour.

Pros of Eyelash Extensions

  1. Customisable: Extensions come in various lengths, thicknesses, and curls, allowing for personalised results tailored to individual preferences.
  2. Instant gratification: Unlike tinting, which requires gradual buildup, extensions provide immediate results, transforming the appearance of lashes in a single session.
  3. Versatility: From natural-looking enhancements to bold, dramatic effects, extensions offer versatility in achieving different lash looks.
  4. Long-lasting: With proper care and maintenance, extensions can last several weeks before needing a refill or touch-up appointment.

Cons of Eyelash Extensions

  1. High maintenance: Extensions require regular upkeep, including avoiding oil-based products, refraining from rubbing or pulling the lashes, and scheduling refill appointments every few weeks.
  2. Risk of damage: Improper application or removal of extensions can lead to damage to natural lashes, including breakage or premature shedding.
  3. Cost: The initial application and maintenance of eyelash extensions can be costly, especially when you factor in refill appointments every few weeks.

Eyelash Tinting vs. Eyelash Extensions: Making the Choice

Deciding between eyelash tinting and extensions ultimately depends on personal preference, lifestyle, and desired results. If you prefer a subtle, low-maintenance enhancement that saves time and money, eyelash tinting may be the ideal choice. On the other hand, if you crave dramatic, customisable lashes and don’t mind the upkeep, eyelash extensions offer a glamorous solution.

Experimenting with DIY at-home eyelash tint kits can be a fun and convenient way to achieve darker, more defined lashes without the need for salon visits. Just remember to conduct patch tests, follow instructions carefully, and prioritize safety.


In conclusion, both eyelash tinting and eyelash extensions have their merits, catering to different preferences and lifestyles. Whether you choose the subtle allure of tinting or the glamorous drama of extensions, the key is to prioritize safety, proper application, and maintenance for stunning results that enhance your natural beauty.

Follow us on Instagram